tablets
  • Best of Year 2014
  • Editors' Choice

Google Nexus 9 Tablet Review

Lollipop, lollipop, oh, lolly-lollypop.

November 21, 2014
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

Introduction

Unlike in some other product categories, the best tablet is often less about having screaming fast hardware than about the experience the software provides. It's the reason why Apple has kept churning out iPads with limited RAM (until this year, anyway), losing the spec sheet war but winning customers over in droves; nobody can expect to get the best tablet simply by looking at a bunch of numbers anymore.

Android—especially on tablets—has long been a Wild West of sizes, shapes, specs, and software, with every manufacturer heading in different directions and ultimately failing to get anywhere. With less of an emphasis on simply having the biggest, baddest tablet in the room, it's no surprise that Google has finally dedicated time into filing down some of Android's rougher edges. With Android 5—codename Lollipop—Google has finally brought a primetime-ready operating system with an incredible mix of stunning design and frictionless code.

The celebrated Nexus 7 may leave big shoes to fill, but Google's Nexus 9 ($399 MSRP) fills them admirably. The tablet isn't a revolutionary leap forward, but it is a fantastic showcase of what's to come with Android's latest iteration. After what we've seen in the lab and at home, it's hard not to be a sucker for Lollipop.

Design

Serious design for a serious tablet

When designing the Nexus 9 in tandem with HTC, it's very clear that Google wanted to build on the success of the LG-made Nexus 5's design. The chassis borrows a soft-touch rubberized coating from the phone, while the brushed-metal edges of the tablet are similarly angled to fit into the crook of your thumb. The hallmark Nexus logo found on the 7, 5, and 10 is also found in the middle of the monochromatic sea of otherwise uninterrupted backing.

google-nexus-9-review-design-buttons.jpg
The buttons are a bit recessed, but very functional.

There are a few key differences from the Nexus 5, however, and many of them center around the rather radical departure from traditional Nexus tablet design. For better or worse, Google and manufacturer pal HTC elected to equip the Nexus 9 with a 4:3 aspect 1536 x 2048 LCD. We've gone in-depth on the advantages of 4:3 on the Apple iPad Air before, and it really comes down to what kind of content you want to watch. 16:9 and similar displays are much better for watching video content, while 4:3 displays give a better experience when viewing web content and photos in both landscape and portrait mode.

google-nexus-9-review-design-speaker.jpg
Front-facing speakers are a godsend on a tablet.

Buyers coming from the Nexus 7 or other 16:10 tablets might get frustrated with the letterboxing on videos, or the slightly improper aspect for reading comics. But otherwise 4:3 is a tried and true aspect ratio, with Apple proving that it's possible to produce a tablet with mass appeal that doesn't offer the best video playback experience.

google-nexus-9-review-design-camera.jpg
It may not look all that pretty, but you won't be using this camera much anyway.

All that aside, Google and HTC did get the little things right on the Nexus 9. Speakers return to the front of the tablet where they had been missing on the 7. This eliminates the need for the annoying hand-cupping needed to direct sound at the user—something Apple still doesn't do. Additionally, all the normal features are on the tablet—standard microUSB cable for file transfers and charging, a notification light, user-facing camera, and unobtrusive side-mounted physical buttons. If you're looking for expandable storage through a microSD card slot, you're out of luck, however.

Though Google didn't give their new tablet's camera a lot of R&D love, that's really okay. It should be obvious, but you shouldn't be using your tablet as a primary camera anyway. Though there are apps out there that require the use of a rear camera, the one on the Nexus 9 is more than good enough. Even the user-facing camera is perfect for video chatting—just don't expect DSLR quality.

Under the hood, Google dropped in NVIDIA's brand new powerhouse K1 processor along with 2 gigabytes of RAM, making this a serious contender when it comes to processing power. Working in tandem with much more efficient software, this is a force to be reckoned with.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Android Lollipop

Sweet software makes for a smooth user experience

It's always a little odd to review tablets from a hardware perspective, given that software optimization is usually the most important part; a more powerful tablet with poor software can easily be outclassed by a lower-specced slate if the OS is better. For Android, the Nexus tablets often accompany landmark versions of Android, showing what the operating system is meant to look and feel like. The Nexus 9 continues this trend, offering an untouched version of Android Lollipop, the most comprehensive update Android's received in years.

google-nexus-9-review-screen-calendar.jpg
The material design updates to system apps are stunning across the board.

For starters, the operating system has a complete aesthetic redesign—what Google calls "Material Design"—that permeates every system app, Google app, and even the Play Store. Material design is meant to evoke the tactile feeling of using physical objects, while still adhering to the more attractive and minimalist flat design principles that have dominated recently. Google's completely redone the core Google Services apps (such as Maps, Mail, the Calendar, and more), and they're universally better looking. As more and more developers start using the new standard look, all your favorite apps will follow these design guidelines, making for a seamless and visually stunning experience.

google-nexus-9-review-screen-lock.jpg
Notifications also live on the lock screen in Android 5.0. View Larger

Google didn't just give Android a fresh coat of paint and call it a day, though. Under the hood, it got a complete overhaul. For each release, the Android team generally focuses on a major sore spot of the previous Android to fix. This time around they focused on updating the software's aging underpinnings (its runtime)—while also boosting battery life.

Project Volta, as it was called, aimed to all but eliminate the persistent and annoying "wakelocks" that would drain battery life while the device's screen wasn't on. For the most part, the project succeeded. There are still some apps that will misbehave, but because the operating system prioritizes functions while asleep, you're left with a battery that'll last you much longer overall.

Additionally, Google switched their runtime over from Dalvik to Android RunTime (ART for short). Though I'm going to skip the salaciously nerdy details here, ART offers better app performance, as well as a reduced memory footprint. This may not get Android running buttery smooth on ancient devices, but it'll allow Android devices to simply do more with less.

google-nexus-9-review-screen-notification.jpg
A two-finger swipe down will open the power menu in the notification drawer.

On top of all that, Google borrowed features from its OEMs—a battery saver mode, a clone of Samsung's Knox security, and Motorola's always listening voice commands. It's a mix of all the best each manufacturer has to offer, but without any of the cruft. Ultimately what you're left with is an attractive operating system that is customizable, runs smoother, and is much more attractive and unified than past versions of Android.

Performance

An ideal platform for Google's new baby

google-nexus-9-review-gamut.png
Blues are wonky, but this color performance is decent. View Larger

So the Nexus lineup got brand new hardware along with a tasty new version of Android, but how does it stack up to other hardware on the market? If you're a gamer, it crushes everything but the NVIDIA Shield tablet. If you don't play more intensive games, the Nexus 9 will still hold up extremely well in most areas. This is one of the best tablets we've ever tested, but I'd be remiss if I didn't point out a few sore spots.

First up is the screen. While the Nexus 9 uses a brilliant display with a wide contrast ratio, the transition from black to white (gamma) is a bit wonky. Not bad, per se, but odd. The rest of the performance metrics are stellar: it has better color, black levels, and contrast than the Nexus' iPad competitors—no small feat. Some users have noted a "light bleed" issue at the top of the screen with early models, but in our unit it was minor at worst. Sample variation could occur, however, so it's something to watch out for.

But what really sets the Nexus 9 apart from its predecessors is the guts inside. Included inside is the Tegra K1, an Nvidia chip that leverages that company's experience designing high-end graphics cards for PCs. It has loads of potential, even if early results haven't quite lived up to expectations. In the Nexus 9 it more than held its own, even when compared to Apple's latest and greatest.

Nexus-9-review-science-3Dmarkfinal.png
The Nexus 9's K1 tops the charts when it comes to 3D gaming.

Holistically speaking, the K1 keeps pace with the iPad Air 2's A8X chip, but there are two very different philosophies at work. The Apple A8X definitely goes out of its way to be able to crunch as much possible data in a single core as possible, while the K1 is purpose-built for handling advanced, multi-threaded applications for things like games with advanced graphics.

For each targeted benchmark we ran, both chips screamed past the competition, but didn't really set themselves apart from each other unless the test was centered around each chip's strength—the K1 drubbed the A8X in 3D rendering, the A8X creamed the K1 in floating point operations. The end result is something of a draw, though for your particular needs one may be better than the other.

Nexus-9-review-sciecne-geekfinal.jpg
Overall Apple's A8x chip is tough to top.

Normally when you see high-powered results like these, there's a massive catch: battery life. It's been common wisdom for a long while that more horsepower under the hood will mean worse gas mileage, but here we see Android's latest improvements really shine. In our labs, the Nexus 9 fared well both our eBook and video battery tests—topping 8 hours, 45 minutes and falling short of 8 hours respectively. With more intensive benchmarks it didn't hold up quite as well, however, but for casual tasks and video watching the Nexus 9 performs admirably.

Conclusion

Every bit as iconic as the Nexus 7

It's no secret that critical reception of the new Nexus 9 has been inconsistent at best. Some people love the Nexus 9, but others have found their review units to be less than stellar. For our part, the Nexus 9 is simply one of the best tablets we've ever seen. It's light, it has a beautiful new version of Android, it has a screaming fast processor, and it has battery life that contends quite easily with Apple's latest iPad Air.

google-nexus-9-review-design-microusb.jpg
A standard microUSB port makes for easy charging

In the lab we were impressed by the benchmarks as well as the excellent battery life, but in real world use the star of the show is Android Lollipop. It's a ground-up rethink of Android that retains all the customizability and flexibility of the operating system but with a far more unified design ethos. And as a Nexus device, the Nexus 9 will continue to receive Google's love with fresh updates for years to come. Only Apple's stable of iPads reliably get that kind of support for the long haul, and it's hard to put a price on that.

In nearly every way, Google and HTC's latest tablet lives up to the excellent name of previous Nexus devices. The one area it doesn't? Value. While the Nexus 7 tablet and Nexus 5 phone have long been synonymous with excellent performance at an excellent price, the $400 Nexus 9 lands very close to Apple territory.

And for everything we love about the Nexus 9, that's a tough price to swallow considering the slicker iPad Air 2 is only $100 more, with its metal-clad chassis and no-fuss interface. By going slightly more expensive the Nexus 9 is a more luxurious showcase for Google's brand-new version of Android. Though some buyers won't want to stray from iOS for any reason, Google's gambit appears to have paid off: the Nexus 9 is downright excellent.

The battery life is stellar, the screen is top-notch (for an LCD), and it's easy to be a sucker for Android Lollipop. Tweet It

Which isn't to say that the Nexus 9 is for everybody. Lovers of iOs will find just as much to love about Apple's new tablet, and may want to even go with the Apple iPad mini with Retina Display to enjoy a lower price and better battery life. The Samsung Galaxy Tab S 8.4" is also excellent, bringing a beautiful OLED display to the tablet and a better aspect ratio for watching videos.

In the end, the Nexus 9 is simply one of the best all-around tablets we've ever tested. It dares to do what most Android tablets have avoided for years: stand toe-to-toe with Apple's premier tablet. It doesn't beat out the iPad Air 2 in every category, but with Lollipop in tow it represents a reasonable alternative for the right buyer.

Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Compare Prices
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

What's Your Take?

All Comments